This is some brief thoughts about Telecomix from a agent, some questions might be answered for some.
Question about price
There have been some claims that the Telecomix services is free of charge, as in free beer. This is not true, and never been true. There is a reason behind this, a very simple one.
Telecomix isn't ...
This is some brief thoughts about Telecomix from a agent, some questions might be answered for some.
Question about price
There have been some claims that the Telecomix services is free of charge, as in free beer. This is not true, and never been true. There is a reason behind this, a very simple one.
Telecomix isn’t a serviceprovider.
We have our services, that is true. But Telecomix isn’t a serviceprovider. If we would take money to use our services, we would be a serviceprovider, and have the responsibility to keep the services online. A price of 0 SEK is also a price. There is no price, and never been a price. We are a group of people that keeps services running, but there is no guarantees that they will keep running. And no one can enforce that we have too. We do it because we think it’s fun, and if others can be helped, that is only a bonus. If a services goes down, well then it is down. And we will probably set it up again, because we use our own services. But there is no price, not even a price of zero.
Free as in freedom, not as in free beer.
You have no right to use our services, it is a privileged use without guarantees. And if the admins think you miss use your chance to stay nice, that is your loss. I promise you, that all admins of Telecomix wants to think the best about people. But that isn’t possible in all cases.
Question about leaders
There have been some discussions that Telecomix does have leaders… Well…
There is no leaders(except from Cameron), but there is serveradmins. All servers needs admins to keep things running. If a server goes down, there is a admin needed to set it up again to keep it running. And he does that, because he wants the service. Usualy the serveradmins of Telecomix have to pay for the serverspace. Infrastructure does cost money. And Telecomix keeps out of the cloud. We do have our own boxes, in our own co-locations that serveradmins pays for from their own pocket.
All serveradmins do have adminpowers in some ways, duh. So if a serveradmin want a change, there will be a change in that direction (maybe!). We have serveradmins that talks to each other and discuss changes before bigger changes is enforced.
And… IRC isn’t a truly decentraliced protocol, you have to have for instance a centernode/tree structure to follow the IRC RFC, which is the case with our network.
Sources to trust
Trust on the internet is a hard question, for everyone. Who can you trust? What info can you trust? Why should you trust?
To work together in a group… you have to trust people in the group. Else the work would fail. If you work alone, and do everything on your own. You don’t need to trust anyone, maybe.
But as a cluster, that do things together, you have to trust at least someone. My protip is to not use services you don’t trust. And that trust isn’t only on protocol level, or encryption, it also includes who the admin is and so on.
I think the best website/feed to trust about what Telecomix is, and what Telecomix do, is telecomix.org website and the telecomix status.net instance and twitterfeed. Just becose a website looks like wikipedia, it does not mean that it’s trustworthy. Comon, everyone can edit, rollback changes, and do edits again. Everyone can create a page with disinfo and link it as source from somewhere else.
Totaly public wikis might contain disinfo.
About the current status of Telecomix
This is my, highly personal thougts. Do not use this as facts.
When I first joined Telecomix, I did it close to the beginning. It was only a few people there and almost only politics, so I left rather quickly. This was rather close to when Telecomix was first launched, and it was much like ‘get more people in!’. I didn’t want to build community back then. I just wanted to sit back and write code. So I left.
Almost a year later, a friend of mine asked me the question… “Why arent you in Telecomix? You would like it there.”, so I joined again. And I had almost forgot about Telecomix, and my experience of it, but when I got there I was met by tons of friendly people. Back then there was never people with op in the channel. Approx 50% of the text in the channel was in Swedish. And everyone was nice to each other. Back then we did politics by sending emails and calling people that works in EU and our own government, to make changes, push changes.
We did replies to some things where the Swedish government asked for opinions from different Organizations. WeRebuild was listed as organization they was interested in to reply. So we got into a pad and wrote a document in LaTeX, compiled, printed and went with the paper to the government.
At this time, I had a great experience every day talking to people in our main-channel, doing some work from time to time.
This has changed, for the last half year(well, more) it have been harder and harder to keep things running. Operators have been attacked, ddosing, tons of more people in the channels that talks(which not have to be bad!). Everyone that hangs around now does not understand how important it is to stay nice to each other. And stay cute together to be able to keep work on what we think is fun.
All systems needs reboots some time, I think, most of the admins wants to go back to this state. Recreate the state where people can hang out together, and have fun together. And have a productive environment. Before there even was thoughts about a price for the Telecomix services. How can anyone even think in that way? How? I don’t get it! I look at it a bit with the same eyes as I look at Free Software with.
The current status of Telecomix is that some parts is closed, we want to calm everyone down. We announced this at the CCCongress in a talk, with a message from Cameron. Systems are going down for reboot. Things are going to change. Not everything is decided yet.